Reporting the financial performance of a range of entities (C8.2)

Definition and nature of a contract

Existence of a Contract:
- A contract exists when an agreement between two or more parties creates enforceable rights and obligations.
- The agreement doesn't need to be in writing, but enforceability is subject to the legal framework of the jurisdiction.
- Enforceability can vary across jurisdictions, and performance obligations may still exist even if not legally enforceable.
Five Criteria for Applying the Revenue Recognition Model:
- Approval & Commitment:
  - The parties must approve the contract and be committed to performing their respective obligations.
  - Even oral or implied contracts can meet this criterion if there’s sufficient evidence of commitment.
- Identification of Rights & Payment Terms:
  - The rights of each party and the payment terms for the goods/services must be identified.
  - In industries like construction, unpriced change orders must be assessed to determine if revenue recognition is appropriate.
- Commercial Substance:
  - The contract must have commercial substance to ensure that it reflects actual economic consequences.
  - Without this, entities might artificially inflate revenue.
- Probable Collection of Consideration:
  - It should be probable that the entity will collect the consideration due under the contract.
  - Customer credit risk assessment is crucial, but it doesn’t affect revenue measurement or presentation.
Unenforceable Contracts:
- The contract doesn't establish enforceable rights and obligations if any of the five criteria are unmet.
- If the contract is not enforceable, revenue recognition should only occur once the contract is complete, canceled, or meets all criteria.
Wholly Unperformed Contracts:
- IFRS 15 does not apply to contracts where all parties can terminate the agreement without penalty before any performance occurs.
- These contracts don’t impact the financial position until performance begins.
Definition of a Customer:
- A "customer" is a party that contracts to obtain goods or services as part of the entity’s ordinary activities in exchange for consideration.
- The definition helps distinguish contracts to be recognized under IFRS 15 from those under other IFRS standards.
- Special cases involve collaborative research, joint arrangements (IFRS 11), or research grants, which may still fall under IFRS 15.
Transfer of Non-Financial Assets:
- IFRS 15 applies to the transfer of non-financial assets that are not part of the entity’s ordinary activities, to determine when to derecognize the asset and recognize the gain or loss.
- These transactions are treated more like asset transfers to customers than typical asset disposals.

Scope, Exclusions, and Interactions with Other IFRS Accounting Standards

1. Exclusions from IFRS 15:

Non-Monetary Exchanges in the Same Industry:
- Transactions involving non-monetary exchanges between entities in the same industry are excluded, as long as they are intended to facilitate sales to customers or potential customers.
- Example: In the oil industry, swapping inventory with another oil supplier to reduce transport costs and facilitate sales to the end customer.
- In such cases, the party exchanging inventory meets the definition of a customer. However, recognizing revenue would lead to an overstatement of both revenue and costs, making it inappropriate under IFRS 15.

2. Exclusions from IFRS 15:

Specific Contracts Outside the Scope:
- Leases (IAS 17 or IFRS 16)
- Insurance Contracts (IFRS 17)
- Financial Instruments & Other Contractual Rights (IFRS 9)
- Consolidated Financial Statements (IFRS 10)
- Joint Arrangements (IFRS 11)
- Separate Financial Statements (IAS 27)
- Investments in Associates & Joint Ventures (IAS 28)
These contracts are outside the scope of IFRS 15.

3. Interaction with Other IFRS Standards:

Partial Application of IFRS 15 and Other Standards:
- Some contracts may partially fall under IFRS 15 and partially under other IFRS standards.
- Example: A lease arrangement with a service contract.
- In such cases, the specific standard (e.g., IFRS 16 for leases) takes precedence in accounting for the relevant part of the contract.
- The residual consideration (i.e., the part of the contract not covered by the other standard) should be accounted for under IFRS 15.
- The transaction price will be reduced by amounts already measured under the other IFRS standard.

4. Application of IFRS 15 Principles:

Understand the Principles First:
- As with all IFRS standards, it's crucial to first understand the core principles of the standard.
- Practical application involves applying these principles to real-world scenarios and contracts.

Key Points:

Exclusions: Non-monetary exchanges in the same industry and contracts under specific IFRS standards like IFRS 9, IFRS 10, and others are outside the scope of IFRS 15.
Interaction: Contracts may be partially governed by other standards (e.g., IFRS 16 for leases), and the parts not covered by those standards are handled under IFRS 15.
Principle-Based Approach: Understanding the core principles of IFRS 15 is essential before applying them to specific contract scenarios.

Assurance Report